Thursday, July 30, 2015

Kia Sorento vs Land Rover Discovery Sport


Kia’s new Sorento aims to mix off-road ability with the premium feel of cars like the Land Rover Discovery Sport. Does it deliver?

The best SUVs on the market need to be fantastic all-rounders to make an impact in such a highly competitive class. They have to deliver the versatility of an MPV and be as comfortable as anexecutive car while still having decent off-road ability. And the latest arrival in the sector is the all-new Kia Sorento.

This third-generation model, as you’d expect, is bigger than ever, and it comes with seven seats as standard. In typical Kia fashion, the Sorento features plenty of kit; but with prices ranging from £29,000 to £41,000, this is one Kia that’s closing in on premium brand territory.


Image 12 of 27

The question is, can it compete in this rarefied atmosphere? To find out, we’ve lined the Sorento up against a car that will test its credentials to the max: the Land Rover Discovery Sport.

The Disco also has seven seats and an upmarket interior, plus it carries a similar price tag. But unlike the Kia, it’s classed as a compact SUV – indeed, it was crowned best in the category at ourNew Car Awards 2015.


Image 27 of 27

Can the Sorento’s larger dimensions give it the edge in this contest? Or is the Discovery Sport enough of a class act to make up for its lack of stature? We tested both models in town, on the motorway and even off-road to see how they measured up.

Click the links above to read individual reviews, and scroll down to see which car comes out on top...

Head-to-head

Practicality


Image 13 of 27

If you often carry seven adults, the Sorento is the car to go for. Its back seats (above) are easier to access, have more head and legroom and are easy to fold. The Disco’s rearmost seats are smaller, as is its boot. Land Rover quotes a 981-litre capacity to the roof, but according to our measurements it has less space under the load cover than the Kia.

Off-road


Image 22 of 27

While the Sorento is the seven-seat choice, the Discovery Sport is the off-road champ. Its Terrain Response system (above) adapts the traction control, engine and box to suit road conditions, while hill descent control is standard. On the Kia, you get hill start assist, but the 4WD system is automatic.

Equipment


Image 21 of 27

Kia doesn’t offer any options aside from metallic paint (£575), but Land Rover allows for a lot of personalisation. There are contrast roof colours and different wheels, while inside you can add plush leather and upgrade the sound system, too.

Verdict

1st place: Land Rover Discovery Sport


Image 14 of 27

It was close, but the Discovery Sport takes victory here with its combination of a high-quality cabin, first-class road manners and decent practicality. Sure, the back seats aren’t the roomiest around, but they’re good enough for most trips, while its off-road ability gives it an advantage. And if you order one now, you’ll benefit from Land Rover’s efficient new diesel (below).

2nd place: Kia Sorento


Image 2 of 27

There’s no doubt that if you want a seven-seater but don’t want to buy an MPV, the Sorento is a great choice due to its roomy back row. It has a spacious boot and is reasonably comfortable, too. Still, while this is the most upmarket Kia yet, it still doesn’t quite match the Land Rover for desirability or quality. We’d recommend one of the lower-spec models instead.

Coming soon... Is it worth waiting for this model?

Land Rover Discovery Sport TD4

Due: September Price: £35,700

Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 178bhp


Order a Discovery Sport now, and your car will feature the new TD4 engine, which emits 139g/km of CO2. That means a 25 per cent Benefit in Kind rate and annual road tax of £130, while fuel economy improves to 53.3mpg.

Key specs:

Land Rover Discovery Sport 2.2 SD4 SE Tech

Kia Sorento 2.2 CRDi KX-3


On the road price/total as tested

£35,700/£35,700

£35,845/£36,420


Residual value (after 3yrs/36,000)

£20,171/56.5%

£17,564/49.0%


Depreciation

£15,530

£18,281


Annual tax liability std/higher rate

£2,131/£4,262

£2,137/£4,273


Annual fuel cost (12k/20k miles)

£1,877/£3,128

£1,412/£2,354


Ins. group/quote/road tax band/cost

34/£571/H/£205

26/£598/G/£180


Servicing costs

£499 (5yrs/50k)

£349 (3yrs/30k)



Length/wheelbase

4,599/2,741mm

4,780/2,780mm


Height/width

1,724/2,069mm

1,685/1,890mm


Engine

4cyl in-line/2,179cc

4cyl in-line/2,199cc


Peak power/revs

187/3,500 bhp/rpm

197/3,800 bhp/rpm


Peak torque/revs

420/1,750 Nm/rpm

422/1,800 Nm/rpm


Transmission

9-spd auto/4WD

6-spd man/4WD


Fuel tank capacity/spare wheel

65 litres/£150

71 litres/full alloy


Boot capacity (7/5/2 seats)

N/A/981**/1,698 litres

142/605/1,662 litres


Kerbweight/payload/towing weight

1,863/737/2,200kg

1,932/658/2,500kg


Turning circle/drag coefficient

11.6 metres/N/A

10.9 metres/N/A


Basic warranty (miles)/recovery

3yrs (unltd)/3yrs

7yrs (100,000)/1yr


Service intervals/UK dealers

16,000 miles (1yr)/130

20,000 miles (1yr)/170


Driver Power manufacturer/dealer pos.

29th/28th*

19th/10th*


Euro NCAP: Adult/child/ped./stars

93/83/69/5

90/83/67/5



0-60/30-70mph

9.0/9.2 seconds

9.0/9.5 seconds


30-50mph in 3rd/4th

3.3/3.6 seconds

3.7/5.0 seconds


50-70mph in 5th/6th/7th/8th

5.5/7.1/8.6/11.0 secs

7.5/9.7 secs/N/A/N/A


Top speed/rpm at 70mph

117mph/1,600rpm

124mph/2,000rpm


Braking 70-0/60-0/30-0mph

63.1/45.3/12.8m (wet)

48.4/34.8/8.9m


Noise outside/idle/30/70mph

69/42/59/68dB

67/45/62/70dB


Auto Express econ (mpg/mpl)/range

35.0/7.7/500 miles

46.5/10.2/726 miles


Govt urban/extra-urban/combined

38.2/49.6/44.8mpg

37.2/53.3/46.3mpg


Govt urban/extra-urban/combined

8.4/10.9/9.9mpl

8.2/11.7/10.2mpl


Actual/claimed CO2/tax bracket

216/166g/km/30%

163/161g/km/30%



Airbags/Isofix/park sensors/camera

Seven/yes/yes/£330

Six/yes/yes/yes


Auto gearbox/stability/cruise control

Yes/yes/yes

£1,755/yes/yes


Clim ctrl/heated leather/elec tailgate

Yes/part/yes

Yes/yes/yes


Metallic paint/xenons/panoramic glass

£600/£950/£950

£575/yes/yes


Sat-nav/USB/DAB radio/Bluetooth

Yes/yes/yes/yes

Yes/yes/yes/yes

Kia Sorento vs Land Rover Discovery Sport Rating: 4.5 Diposkan Oleh: le loi

Related Posts :

0 nhận xét :

Post a Comment